My take on the Mahout and Myrrix recommendation algorithms

MahoutWhereas BestComparator has his own recommendation engine based on user profiling, behavior analysis and analysis of product specs, I recently wanted to explore the possibilities of the famous recommendation engine built inside Mahout.

First of all, Mahout is a set of machine learning algorithms which leverage the Hadoop environment, providing powerful and scalable algorithms. One of its main target is the recommendation algorithms also known as taste collaborative filtering.

Recommendation algorithms have been made famous by websites such as Amazon, Youtube or Netflix. They use it to make suggestions based on what you bought, watched or liked.


MyrrixOne of the author of Taste/Mahout recommender engine, Sean Owen decided to give the engine a more formal structure by building Myrrix.

Myrrix is a recommendation engine based on Mahout. It offers an out of the box configuration for a recommendation engine accessible with a Rest API. The good to know are:

  • Scalable as Mahout and Hadoop are scalable, using computing parallelization and a distributed file system
  • Runs an optimized version of Taste (currently Taste 3)
  • Runs in real time
  • Can be efficient even with a relatively small amount of data

Recommendation process

The first thing you want to do is to feed your model (ie. Your algorithm) with current observed data. The models aggregates users, items and the associations between them. These associations are called preferences and are qualified by their value, describing the strength of the association between the user and the item.

Feeding the engine means pushing every observed associations with the user id, the item id and the strength. You are simply giving the engine your current taste graph, linking users to items via their tastes.

When your engine is fed, you have to ask it to refresh. Thus it will re-analyze the given graph and compute an actualized, and thus better, model. This may take some time, but Myrrix has the ability to continue answer your requests during this time.

Finally, with your shinny model you can ask questions and get recommendations. Here are the main queries:

  • Recommend to a user
  • Recommend to a group of users
  • Recommend to an anonymous user
  • Recommend similar items
  • Estimate the strength of the preference between an user and an item

With such a panel of tools you can easily guess that answering the question “What item users like me also liked?” becomes accessible.

Consuming Myrrix from PHP

PHPIn order to integrate Myrrix results to my recommendation engine, I had to build a PHP Myrrix client. I decided to use the Guzzle library that provides a really neat way of building a PHP client for Rest APIs. You can download my library on the open source Github Project:

After installing the library, you can write some very fancy code:

// Get a client
$this->client = MyrrixClient::factory(array(
    'hostname' => 'localhost',
    'port'     => 8080,

// Put a user/item assocation, here use #101 as an association of strength 0.5 with item #1000
$command = $this->client->getCommand('PostPref', array(
    'userID' => 101,
    'itemID' => 1000,
    'value'  => (string)0.5,

// Refresh the index
$command = $this->client->getCommand('Refresh');

// Get a recommendation for user #101
$command = $this->client->getCommand('GetRecommendation', array(
    'userID' => 101,
$recommendation = $this->client->execute($command)->json();

Here we instantiate a Myrrix client hosted on the localhost on port 8080. We put into the model a preference of 0.5 between the user #101 and the item #1000. We then ask the model to refresh. Finally we get a recommendation for the user #101. The recommendation result is an array of item id with their estimated strength for the given user.

The library is pretty straight forward and help you leverage in a very simple way all the powerfulness of the Myrrix engine from PHP.

I also made a Symfony Bundle that helps you get the client from the dependency container, and offers a cleaner configuration process:

Don’t hesitate to get the code, install it and test it. I would be very happy to get contributions, feedbacks or feature requests.


About work, open source and commitment

With this post, I want to take some time to explain my commitment to open source, especially to Symfony and how it is tangled with my everyday work.

What do I do?

I am currently developing for my new startup I founded with two of my associates and friends. We knew each other at engineer school ECE Paris, and were always hungry for entrepreneurship. We worked together for years now, and had some ideas on the way. Some were bad, some were better, and one was genial enough to deserve a real leap into the world of startup creation.

And so we created BestComparator.


BestComparatorIt is service that helps everyday consumer to choose the best product according to his profile, his urges, and the general quality vs. price value of the products available on the market.

Our ultimate goal is to make the best product recommendation answering this simple sentence: “I am Michel, I am a 23 years old nerd, I need a new Laptop, and most of my time I develop, listen to podcasts and surf on the web.”

We worked really hard, developing the service, creating partnership with price comparison services, and defining exactly how the UX/algorithm would look like. We starting working full time on September 2011. We released an early private preview on October and a public beta on March 2012.

The service is finally online since July 2012 and we already have some nice recommendations and the business is smoothly starting.

This is just a start and many thing could be, and will be, better in the coming months. We also have a heavy roadmap, containing very nice (killer) features, more products, better recommendations, an ecosystem, and some other surprises.

So what do I do in that venture?

BestComparator is a 3 men job. While my associates work on the business and the UX, I spend my time coding the foundations of the service. I am the Data, Architecture, Algorithm, Information System guy. AKA the CTO/Lead developer/Cofounder.

The challenge is quite big. We have to aggregate, consolidate and extract meaning from a gigantic amount of data, from products specifications to our member’s behaviors and desires. Those are coming through various funnel, from our partners, the socials networks, what the users say and don’t say… I needed a solid base with a solid promise.

Three years ago I was already a symfony 1.4 junky. This was with tremendous thrill that I started working with Symfony2 nearly two years ago when the first preview appeared. I saw in Symfony2 a very powerful tool moving at a fast pace, bringing many new core concepts to the PHP world (bundles, annotation, DI…), and gathering a very prolific community. Symfony2 is scalable, fast, flexible and stable. Most of all, it made PHP better with a modern architecture and better practices. Its strength is well known and since we adopted it Drupal, eZ Publish, phpBB and many more followed the way.

As a proof of or commitment you can have a look at the credit page at BestComparator.

As you can see we have a quite exhaustive architecture, composed around Symfony2.1 we are running on Doctrine2.3, ElasticSearch, Behat, Sonata, Assetic, Twig and many more.

I also committed to a community

Of course we started when Symfony2 was young, and in some ways it still is young. Along the way, I was involved in some features of the framework (especially around the translation components), and I pushed into the Sonata project for instance. I also developed some standalone bundles such as the BCCExtraToolsBundle, the BCCCronManagerBundle… which are quite famous now.

Developing such bundles requires time. I love to spend it working on open source projects, especially when it matters to people. Thus, I am very happy today when I can work on BCC Bundles, designed for BestComparator and pushed to the open world.

As a bonus I also develop some C# apps for Windows Phone 7: Gi7 and Readr7. They are open source, and some other might come around the Windows 8 platform.

I try to allocate as much energy that I can, following, debugging and improving these projects. That’s my second commitment.

How about a third commitment

Also I am getting married teaching programming at ECE Paris for a year now. Mostly C and C#, I also have some involvement in some web development and Java courses.

I do it partly because it allow me to earn enough money to pursue my work at BestComparator and mostly because I like to share.

I can also tell you that committing to a hundreds of students is not a so easy commitment and it requires time and patience (and patience too).

Follow up

First of all I enquire to go on BestComparator, things are French for the moment, as long as we need some contracts with local resellers. Here are the common way of getting updates on the venture: twitter, facebook, g+.

You can watch and fork my work on github, and pack your PHP projects on packagist. My windows apps are on the market place.

And if you are interesting in a very prolific and fast growing engineer school (with very talent teachers of course), go have a look on the ECE Paris website.

The BCCEnumerableUtility is out

The BCCEnumerableUtility is out

One of the most frustrating things you may encounter as a PHP developer is definitely the lack of clarity and consistency of many of the core array and string manipulation functions.

What goes wrong

Let’s take for example the function that checks if a string contains another string. You might want to use strstr but you should use strpos for performance purpose. You already noticed the lack of clarity in the name of the functions, and the fact that whatever you do, the better way of dealing with strings in php is never straightforward.
You may also know that the case insensitive equivalents of these function adds an i in the middle of their names (stristr, stripos). Again, this is not very explicit. Finally, some functions does not respect the same format, such as str_split or str_replace.

And the same matters occur with the array functions.

As you may know, I also have a .NET background, especially in C#. One of the thing I like is the way they deal with this issue. First of all, strings and arrays are objects… They also have the IEnumerable interface that is implemented by everything that is an enumeration of items (strings are enumeration of characters). They added a bunch a generic methods that extends the IEnumerable interface to provide clear and powerful functionalities. So whenever you have something that is enumerable you leverage automatically tens of filtering, ordering, transformation and manipulation functions.

I really miss IEnumerable when I am using PHP.

The BCCEnumerableUtility

When PHP5.4 came out, I saw in traits a way to port IEnumerable from C# to PHP.

So I mimicked the C# interface and made the Enumerable trait, with the Collection and String classes that leverage the trait.

Let’s avoid taking too much, here is an example with the Collection class that leverage the trait:

select(function($item) { return $item*$item; })->average();

// filter the even numbers and then order
$values->where(function($item) { return $item%2 == 0; })->orderBy();

The Enumerable trait comes with a bunch of nice functions that you can discover on the BBCEnumerableUtility Github repository.

The String class

The library also provides a String class that adds some string dedicated functions:

replace('world', 'pineapple') // replace world by pineapple
->toUpper() // to upper case
->skip(6) // skip the 6 first letters
->takeWhile(function($char) { $char != '!'; }); // take the rest while the char is different from '!'

echo $string; // PINEAPPLE

I know many people won’t like the idea of a String class, so I provide a StringUtility helper that gives you access to all the functionality with static calls:

use BCCEnumerableUtilityStringUtility;

$string = 'Hello world!';

$string = StringUtility::replace ($string, 'world', 'pineapple'); // replace world by pineapple
$string = StringUtility::toUpper ($string); // to upper case
$string = StringUtility::skip ($string, 6); // skip the 6 first letters
$string = StringUtility::takeWhile($string, function($char) { $char != '!'; }); // take the rest while the char is different from '!'

echo $string; // PINEAPPLE

Wrap up

The BCCEnumerableUtility library will help you manipulate strings and arrays more easily.

As usual, I published this library on Github. I welcome remarks, bugs and contributions 🙂

Welcome the BCCCronManagerBundle, the Symfony2 bundle that helps you managing your crons

Welcome the BCCCronManagerBundle, the Symfony2 bundle that helps you managing your crons

One thing I don’t like to do when maintaining a website, is having to pull out ssh on a daily basis in order to check that everything is running fine. A basic use case is scheduling and watching crons.

So I recently came out with the idea of building a web interface wrapping the use of the crontab command with some tools for watching associated log files.

And thus, the BCCCronManagerBundle was born.

A quick presentation

The BCCCronManagerBundle can already do some nice things:

  • display the cron entries of the cron table, parsing time expression, command, output file, error file and comment
  • guess the last execution time and status
  • display log files
  • add, edit and remove cron entries

The bundle is localized in english and french. The forms also include some shortcuts t easily build common time expression, launch a symfony command or log in the symfony log directory.

The cron list
The cron list
The cron form
The cron form
A cron log file
A cron log file

How it works

Actually, the architecture is quite simple. Everything relies on two classes: CronManager and Cron.

The CronManager launches the [cci]crontab -l[/cci] command in constructor, then extracting each lines in order to build a collection of Cron instance. It has get, add and remove methods in order to access the Cron collection. A raw method build up the cron table string based on the Cron collection and a write method puts it into a temporary file before launching the [cci]crontab $file[/cci] command.

The Cron class is instantiated using the parse static method. Its job is to parse a cron line from the cron table and extract the time expression, command, output, error output and comment (if defined). Based on the output files it can guess if the cron has already been runned (one of the output files is present) and if it was successful or not (the error file is empty). A getExpression method can build the time expression and the _toString is overriden in order to give the cron representation for the cron table.

The interface is quite neat, thanks to Sam. He helped me implementing the twitter bootstrap which is very powerfull and elegant. I also decided to make use of the jQuery plugin that is quite impressive and can easily replace jQueryUI on some points.

Wrap up

You can download and install the bundle on the github :
I also welcome contributions for any improvement, such as a better cron table parsing, more options for cron definition (such as log files), better support of multi platforms, or translations.

BCCExtraToolsBundle for Symfony2 now includes new features

BCCExtraToolsBundle for Symfony2 now includes new features

The purpose of this blog post is to review the last features that have been included into the BCCExtraToolsBundle.
As you may know, its current main feature is a command that extract translation string from your template and dump them into your translation files. It has been so popular that the code has been adapted and merged it into the code Framework a few months ago with the help of the community.
Sadly, I will eventually remove this functionality from the bundle when the 2.1 version will come out. Hopefully, I recently add new cool stuffs into the Bundle recently that you may find useful.

A date parser

You may know that the Bundle currently includes a date formatter that provides you a nice way to localize your dates directly with a twig filter.
I reviewed the code recently to provide a way to make the operation working the other way. You can now do such things :


// obtain a datetime instance for a normally formated string
$date = $dateFormatter->parse(‘November 1, 2011’);

// obtain a datetime instance using a defined locale
$date = $dateFormatter->parse(‘1 Novembre 2011, 20;14’, ‘fr’);

// obtains a datetime instance with a uncommon string
$date = $dateFormatter->parse(‘Nov. 2011);


Basically, the code is trying every parsing it can using the formats available for the formatter (more information here and more so that it can parse almost anything.
Of course it can be very handy when you consume some weird API using nonstandard datetime formatting.

A unit converter

About consuming API. I can be very annoying to find some values in a unit don’t want to use. The unit formatter is here to help you:



// transform a value knowing the source and destination units
echo $unitConverter->convert(1000, ‘m’, ‘km’); // echoes : 1

// transform a value knowing only the destination units
echo $unitConverter->guessConvert(‘1h’, ‘m’); // echoes : 60


To do such work, your value will go through different phases::
– A chain unit converter will try to convert using its DI registered unit converters
– A ratio unit converter which converts units that are strictly proportional will take care of most your conversion
– The ratio unit converter supports different kind of units registered using DI, such as length, weight, speed, time… those are called ratio unit providers
– Ratio units providers defines units and ratios related to a specific unit kind. It includes also the locale where the unit is applicable and the prefixes that can be associated to the unit. For instance, the computer capacity unit kind will define the octet, the bit and the byte with their corresponding conversion ratio and the applicable prefixes (k, M, G…).

With such a structure, the converter insure you that any prefix is taken into account, that the conversion is done between coherent units (it won’t try to convert time into money… sadly), and it also takes into account your current locale (the ‘metre’ is the french unit for the ‘meter’).

I’ll try to add more units and documentation in the coming posts.

Wrap up

The BCCExtraToolsBundle continues to provide useful features to the developers. Get the code of the datetime parser and the unit converter on the BCCExtraToolsBundle github : Don’t hesitate to report issues, feedback and improve the code 🙂

Introduce the BCCAutoMapperBundle for Symfony2

Introduce the BCCAutoMapperBundle for Symfony2

One of my favorite tools with my .NET developments is definitely AutoMapper. It allows to easily mapping objects to other objects by generating default maps for graph of objects base on the name of the different members.

I found it quite a shame that such a tool did not exist on the PHP platform. So I started a new Symfony2 bundle to palliate this lack.

How the AutoMapperBundle works

You can find it here:

As a quick example here to show you how you can map objects together. Here is your model:

name = $name;
$this->description = $description;
$this->author = new SourceAuthor($author);

public getName() {
return $this->name;

public getDescription() {
return $this->description;

public getAuthor() {
return $this->author;

class SourceAuthor {
private $name;

public __construct($name) {
$this->name = $name;

public getName() {
return $this->name;

class DestinationPost {
private $title;
private $description;
private $author;

public getTitle() {
return $this->title;

public setTitle($title) {
$this->title = title;

public getDescription() {
return $this->description;

public setDescription($description) {
$this->description = description;

public getAuthor() {
return $this->author;

public setAuthor($author) {
$this->author = author;

Then, in you application:

// create default map and route members
$mapper->createMap(‘MySourcePost’, ‘MyDestinationPost’)
->route(‘title’, ‘name’)
->route(‘author’, ‘’);

// create objects
$source = new SourcePost(‘AutoMapper Bundle’, ‘A great bundle’, ‘Michel’);

// map
$destination = $mapper->map($source, $new DestinationPost());

echo $destination->getTitle(); // outputs ‘AutoMapper Bundle’
echo $destination->getDescription(); // outputs ‘A great bundle’
echo $destination->getAuthor(); // outputs ‘Michel’

Read the doc on the github to find more explanation and more functionalities:

This is a very light implementation and some cases are not covered yet (such as dynamic graph creation). Please, don’t hesitate to fork me and provide feedback.